Urban myth? We think not. There are actually people out there who have done the impossible. They have LEFTOVER HALLOWEEN CANDY! Bizarre, we say, as we attempt to zip up our pants and hide 75 tiny wrappers at the same time.

Sadly, or happily (we can’t decide which), we’ve spent the last weeks trying desperately to not to OD on those sweet nuggets of happiness—unsuccessfully, obviously. In fact, it was a glory day when we realized we were going to eat the little suckers anyway, so we turned the hedonism into an innovative grown up experience, replete with wine and candy pairings.

Truth: Halloween treats are a sugary indulgence we just can’t resist. For some reason, candy tastes better when it comes a tiny package. But, if you’ve got a semblance of self control, or you’ve simply confiscated excess contraband, then you’ll love this collection of delightful recipes we’ve curated that will put those leftover treats to great use. In fact, they’re so good, you’ll making them again. Hey, did you know they sell mini-sized candy all year round? Ready to satisfy your sweet tooth?

Start with this recipe developed just for you by Brazen Insider Beth Warren (you can find her at Beth the Baker).


YOUR FAVOURITE CHOCOLATE BAR CHEESECAKE BARS Leftover Halloween Candy Mini Chocolate Bar Cheesecake Bars


  • 10 wafer-type snack-sized chocolate bars like Kit Kit, Coffee Crisp, Twix, or a combination of all
  • 8 mini Mars bars (or a combo of other leftover chocolate bars)
  • 1 8 oz package of cream cheese
  • 3 tbsp milk
  • 1 egg
  • 1/2 tsp vanilla
  • 1/4 cup sugar


1. Butter an 8 x 8 baking dish (or spray with cooking spray). Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.

2. Chop the wafer-type bars into tiny pieces or coarsely grind them in a food processor. They should be the consistency of graham cracker crumbs. Spread evenly in the bottom of the pan, and press down. This is your crust. Don’t worry if it’s not solid, the filling and melted chocolate will hold it in place.

3. Mix cream cheese, milk, egg, sugar and vanilla together either with a wooden spoon or with a mixer. It should be smooth and free of lumps. Pour over the crust.

4. Chop the Mars bars into small pieces and sprinkle over the top.

5. Bake for 12-15 minutes or until the filling is set.

6. Cool to room temperature. Cut into 16 pieces (or less if you like larger chunks) then chill in fridge or freezer until ready to serve.

Want more? That’s a rhetorical question. Click through the slideshow below.

A Collection of Recipes that Use Leftover Halloween Candy

By BrazenWoman

Got any treats left over? Want to get them out of the house? Try these yummola and very decadent recipes we've curated from around the web.

  • Halloween Chocolate Bark with Halloween Candy

    By BrazenWoman

    If you like chocolate bark you'll love this trio using leftover chopped up Halloween treats from Food. Love. Happiness.

  • Grain-Free Cookie Dough Energy Bits

    By BrazenWoman

    Ok so this one isn't so naughty. In fact, these bites will make you feel like you're doing your body good and not indulging yet again. We do love balls!

  • Vegan Chocolate Caramel Popcorn

    By BrazenWoman

    Lurch! These don't use leftover Halloween treats per se, but it is delicious and we're thinking not-so-bad for you. If you've ripped open too many little packets then this is the one for you.

  • Rice Crispy Caramilk Bars

    By BrazenWoman

    Ok these are our favourite childhood treat x 1000000. No explanation necessary. STOP DROOLING!

  • Mars Bars Brownies

    By BrazenWoman

    Talk about chocolatey deliciousness. Fudge, caramel, nougat…These brownies just scream PMS. Make them. Then hide them from yourself.

  • World's Best Butterfinger Pie

    By BrazenWoman

    The only thing confusing to us about this recipe is that there would ever be tiny Butterfingers left over. Those guys are elusive. This decadent pie is easy to make and will disappear faster than your local ghost.

  • Candylicious Cookies

    By BrazenWoman

    Yah, we know. It's hard to improve on chocolate chip cookies. But this baker seems to have accomplished something great. How to: Chop up treats, mix into cookie dough. Eat.

  • Halloween Candy Cookie Cake

    By BrazenWoman

    You had us at Candy + Cookie + Cake. A picture says a thousand words, yes?

  • Leftover Halloween Candy Brownie Trifle

    By BrazenWoman

    So what is a trifle but a layered bowl of deliciousness? And this one really has just about everything in it. That's been stolen from some unsuspecting kids' trick or treat stash.

bake withFeatured image: Food.Love.Happiness

About the author

Brazen Woman

BrazenWoman Editors share the latest and greatest tips, trends, reviews, contests and giveaways.

Get Brazen In Your Inbox

Sign up to receive our daily or weekly newsletter.